Average Customer Reviews
Energy Star Rated - No
Need more help?
Like this category?
(based on 76 reviews)
of respondents would recommend this to a friend.
Most Liked Positive Review
overall good but noisy at times
We bought this fridge because our doors were narrow. It is a nice looking fridge and we are mostly happy with it, but something clicks on/off and makes a humming noise. It...Read complete review
We bought this fridge because our doors were narrow. It is a nice looking fridge and we are mostly happy with it, but something clicks on/off and makes a humming noise. It scares the dogs at times! We also didn't expect the drawers to be such a flimsy plastic. It is not a popular model, so it wasn't on the floor. My recommendation is to ALWAYS see the product before you purchase it.
Most Liked Negative Review
Expected more from Maytag
We had to buy a smaller refrigerator to fit in a specific spot in our kitchen. We decided on Maytag for quality and reputation, and fit. We even opted for the more expensive...Read complete review
We had to buy a smaller refrigerator to fit in a specific spot in our kitchen. We decided on Maytag for quality and reputation, and fit. We even opted for the more expensive Eco-Conserve more-energy efficient model. While it serves the bbasic functions of a fridge (chills and freezes), we have had issues.(1) Storage: Maybe it's the function of the new bottom-freezer models, but we hate storing our frozen goods in a literal PILE in the freezer compartment. In addition, the fridge shelves are difficult to configure for tall and or very wide items. For instance, you cannot put two shelves side by side to make one wide/across shelf, as they don't fit! Silly!(2) Performance: We discovered water leaking at the same time for 3 days running around the front feet. Turns out there is a build up of ice as a frozen pond in the bottom of the freezer that oozes out as water upon the defrost cycle of the fridge engaging. Investigating this on the internet, I understand that my "drain" might be frozen. Who has ever heard of this?? Fridges are supposed to be plug-and-play and wait 25 years until your next appliance. And why so hard to get to the drain, even?We are still in warranty mode. I'll phone for info about the drain issue, but this bums us out.
Subscribe to Reviews
Reviewed by 76 customers
Displaying reviews 1-10
Back to top
Previous | Next »
Love my new refrigerator
By LA in OH
from Carrollton, OH
Comments about Maytag MBF1958WES Stainless Steel Bottom Freezer Refrigerator:
Replaced 20-year-old refrigerator with this one. Love the bottom freezer and full-width deli drawer. Sturdy handles are a great feature.
Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Was this review helpful? Yes / No
- You may also flag this review
Comment on this review
from Clear Lake, IA
bought because of the quality and the ease, functionality of the bottom freezer.
By Stephen's Mom
from Framingham, MA
I love it! With glass shelves and see-through drawers and bins, I can see everything at a glance. Nothing is hidden! I am very happy I bought this one!
By Remodel Addict
from Detroit Lakes, MN
I am very happy with this refrigerator! It fits in the small space I had to work with, its a bottom freezer (which is hard to find in this size) and I love the commercial feel of the handles. I also greatly appreciate the 10 year warranty on the compressor.
from Liberty NY
He size was perfect for my space(built in).
I've had this refridgerator for a month or so and am pleased with it thus far. I like the flexible shelf locations and the drawer configurations. I don't care for the ice drawer location in the back of the freezer. Ice often spills from the container when you pull the freezer out to access the ice. It certainly is an upgrade from my old unit and I look forward to the energy savings.
Roomier than you expect
from Baldwin, NY
I bought this to replace a 14 year old refridgerator that died. I wanted a stainless steel with freezer on bottom. I had a very small opening which left me with only this choice. I was worried that it would be too small, but not only is it roomy, but its interior design makes it easy to organize things.
from Decorah, IA 52101
My refrigerator is so quiet you can't tell when it is running! Love the look, space and most of all the pull out freezer with ice maker. I can see everything in the freezer with a glance.
from Portsmouth, VA
Great fit and finish, has everything i need and some. Love the LED lighting.
By Matt the Cooler
from Burlington, WI
I have been very happy with my Maytag fridge. It is easy to use, has great storage and allows for a number of different sized items.
Delivery is subject to reasonable access to the area without damaging the purchaser's property or the product, or jeopardizing the safety of the delivery personnel.
Fill out the form below to request Better Price for this product.
Sign up for the latest information on new products, special offers, and savings opportunities at Abt and receive $25 off your next order of $250 or more.