Average Customer Reviews
Energy Star Rated - No
(based on 2792 reviews)
of respondents would recommend this to a friend.
Most Liked Positive Review
Great product without the unnecessary frills!
We upgraded our older, smaller refrigerator and did tons of research and based on the reviews of this product and the dimensions fitting our kitchen decided on this refrigerator and I am glad we...Read complete review
We upgraded our older, smaller refrigerator and did tons of research and based on the reviews of this product and the dimensions fitting our kitchen decided on this refrigerator and I am glad we did. It does not have all the bells and whistles as other, more expensive ones do, but it has plenty of capacity and is quiet and looks great! It is great for smaller kitchens like we have but still has tons of interior space. It fit perfectly in our space and having the refrigerator at eye level is a huge back saver. If you want a very nice, quiet and adjustable refrigerator without all the unnecessary frills and have a smaller spot to put it, then this is most definitely the one for you! I highly recommend it!
Most Liked Negative Review
Ugly visible screws on front door
I purchased this refrigerator 4/20/2015 and read reviews and even enlarged pictures to get a better view. However, when the frig arrived, there were two (2) unsightly screws on the...Read complete review
I purchased this refrigerator 4/20/2015 and read reviews and even enlarged pictures to get a better view. However, when the frig arrived, there were two (2) unsightly screws on the front door opposite the handle. Because you can change the door handle, the screws are there but what an awful sight. Not sure if I'll be able to get used to it. Very unsightly for a stainless refrigerator. Also, freezer basket does not pull out that far.
Reviewed by 2792 customers
Displaying reviews 1-10
Back to top
Previous | Next »
Comments about Maytag MBF1958WEB Black Bottom Freezer Refrigerator:
2 weeks old happy replaced a 5 year old samsung
Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Was this review helpful? Yes / No
- You may also flag this review
from east wareham,ma
it is just right for our use
from Northampton Pa
Good quality, well made, easy to grip handle
When the compressor has a 10 year limited warranty, that speaks for itself. I appreciate that. I like to have some reassurance that I won't be having repair bills.
Prefer top Mount
By Lisa Maniscalco
from Staten Island, NY
I am really not thrilled with this refrigerator. It is louder than my previous 10 year old Kenmore Elite. I removed all my items from my (2/3 full) top freezer and put them into my new bottom freezer. It was so full I couldn't add a toothpick! I can't believe how much less the bottom mount holds. The little lever on the crisper for humidity control broke day 2.
Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend
Very happy with this fridge.
By Mike D.
from New Jersey
Very happy with this refrigerator. I do recommend the models with the freezer on the bottom if you don't opt for side-by-side or French door models. Much better than old style top freezer models and less expensive than the other models mentioned.
from Kamas, Utah
Ice maker stopped working after 6 months. No water filter on this model.
We've had this refrigerator for a month and I'm very happy with the amount of space it has and how nice it looks. We have three hungry teenagers so we need our refrigerator to hold a lot of food. My only complaints are that I wish the crisper drawers could be a little deeper and sometimes it seems noisy or high pitched. However, these are minor issues and I don't regret purchasing this refrigerator.
Finger Resistant Bottom Mount Refrigerator
By Love my new Refrigerator
We have been using our new refrigerator for a couple weeks now. So far we are loving it. The freezer on the bottom is great! No more standing on your head to see what is in the refrigerator! No finger prints all over the front, love the finger resistance. It is well organized inside and has a nice bright light inside. It did have a broken grill base in front. Gave Maytag a call and one is on the way.
from Grand Rapids, MI
I really like having the refrigerator on top. It makes it so much easier to see everything and there is no bending. It's also very well lit and I like the way the shelves are arranged and I have the option to move them around- as well as the ones in the door if I want them a different way.The freezer is nice- it is well lit- which is new to me. I do think there is not as much room as in my old freezer and it's kind of tight at times with the pull out drawer feature. And there doesn't seem to be much room at all on the top shelf if you want to keep ice in there. I don't know how this can be improved upon and we are making it work, just wish it was a little bigger and or a little better designed. But we do like the fridge and are happy to have it.
Delivery is subject to reasonable access to the area without damaging the purchaser's property or the product, or jeopardizing the safety of the delivery personnel.
Fill out the form below to request Better Price for this product.
your next order of $250 or more.